The way beautiful deer
runs hard to safe its life from a furious hungry lion running after to prey and
the way it is killed, depresses many people of weak hearts like mine …. OK. Let
us stand against that brutal act and pass a bill that no animal will be preyed
by other animal…. If done , tell me how you will accommodate those animals who
are carnivores …. Surely they will die of hunger … Now which way you will
devise between to save both????? Inject all animals and make them vegetarian.
But this is not possible on real grounds, at least one have to suffer.
I want to talk about the action
taken by Government of Denmark who have banned the slaughtering of animals by
religious way to meet the demands of halal and kosher meat for Muslim and Jewish
population in the country .
This action have been
taken after long movement from different protesting groups over the years. Some
people have condemned the action and said that it is clearly an unjust interference
in religious sensibilities and activities of a particular group of people.
It is claimed by Danish
minister that , "animal rights come before religion”. According to a news source
on ;
I was just wondering as many
people are protesting against any act performed by the certain people according
to their religion but the government have no concern about the living
conditions of animals and what for their own pigs how they are treated
throughout their lives and the way they are being breed, is that not against
animal rights??? Is not that miserable, unjust and painful? Why this is ignored
but are more concerned and anxious about the pain animal have while being slaughtered
religiously.
In some countries animals
are stunned to give them least pain possible before slaughtering but many Muslims
do not feel it right as it is said that it lowers the heart beat and the blood
does not comes out of body properly comparatively while slaughtering without
being stunned. During stunning it is also a case that animal may die prior to
slaughtering. Many different methods are used across the world for stunning
like:
Pitching
Electric Shock stunning
Water bath Stunning
Gas stunning etc.
It is claimed that it
lowers the pain but nothing can be said for sure. I am sorry to say , as no man
have volunteered him for the test. But I think it actually doubles the pain as
you are first stunning them , then slaughtering. Some methods of stunning are
even being banned in many countries , considering them to be painful.
It is necessary for Muslims
and Jews to slaughter animal when it is alive in a certain way, even any animal
if run over by vehicle or attacked by any other animal or hunted or caught by
dogs etc. can be slaughtered and used , if was alive prior to slaughtering.
Consumption of stunned
animals is prohibited by Jews , they must be having some solid reason behind. For
the Muslims we have clear instructions from Prophet Mohammad ( peace and
blessings be upon him);
“Verily Allah has
prescribed proficiency in all things. Thus, if you kill (an animal), kill well;
and if you slaughter, slaughter well. Let each one of you sharpen his blade and
let him spare suffering to the animal he slaughters” (Sahih Muslim).
I find this little
hypocritical that they just want to enforce their law keeping aside the
religious requirements of the people . They claim that it hurts animals but
what about so many people among Muslims and Jews around the globe that are
hurt after getting this news. Keeping aside the sensitivity of the matter they
just want to comfort their nerves and as its their country they want their laws
enforced by hook or by crook. Apart from what will be faced and felt by the minorities. Freedom of rights is
affected. Where are human right organizations now?
So we are showing more
concern towards animals and least towards humans that are not of same belief as
ours. What about hundreds of the people being slaughtered everyday in different
corners of the world. Aren’t they that much least important to be thought about?
Everyone is pretty aware
of the facts about frozen foods it will surely
have adverse affects on human health , and they do not care, only animal’s
rights are more important.
Alas humanity have no
value, there is no care about humans in many societies around the globe and
they stand for animal rights.
WOW!!!
It’s necessary that the
citizens should be respected and protected by the country but it’s sad that
their condition is made pitiable and they are made weak and are segregated. The
population of Muslims and Jews is very
small in the country and it is sad that even a small number of people are not respected
and cared about.
Comparing this condition
with rest of many western countries like UK , Canada, USA where majority of
Muslims and Jews living and law have legalized and allowed the freedom of
religion and slaughtering of animals. I will also like to add , if some action
like this have been taken in those countries then the reaction should have been
different as minorities are in influence in those countries.
I was even wondering it’s
legal to have horse races and the way they are whacked on butts to run even
harder , Oh ya! that is fine , as it amuse them. The way animals are injected
by hormones and germs during experiments , that is fine too….the way animals
are killed and fed to beasts in their zoo … still no worries….. The way they
are caged and kept under bars … It’s still fine as all these brutal acts and
barbarism has nothing to do with any religion different than theirs.
This is rule of nature ,
animals are made for humans to get benefits from them like transportation and eventually
food.
This is law of nature and animals are destined to be treated the way they are.!!! I would say there are many more important issues relating humans in the world to stand for. First solve all of them , then in next step move towards animals.
This is law of nature and animals are destined to be treated the way they are.!!! I would say there are many more important issues relating humans in the world to stand for. First solve all of them , then in next step move towards animals.
But I am happy that halal
and kosher meat can still be imported from abroad , let’s wait and see when
they will say something against this.
There is some kind of
politics behind , who want to torture specific group of people and wants to please
some. Some of affected people regret being part of such country where there is
no protection and freedom of their rights. This act has marginalized the
minorities.
I hope keeping in mind
the preferences of their people they will roll back this law and give their
people a place to live and practice their religions peacefully and with full
freedom. This will help indicating , them having secular law.
What is your opinion about this issue ? Do you feel it right to consume animals being stunned before slaughtering ???
I will be happy to have your feed back on this serious issue.
tOOO LONG
ReplyDeleteI agree hahaha bt it was realy intresting n thought provaking
Deletenice article.yeah humanity is more important than animals rights.
ReplyDeletethank you tahira
Deleteyou are right in saying that
This law demonstrates a strange set of priorities. Where I live in Canada many people who are neither Muslim nor Jewish buy Halal or Kosher meat . Sometimes this is because they are entertaining friends who are devout. More often it is simply because they appreciate the quality. I think animal activists should be more concerned about the inhumane conditions in which many animals are raised. What next ... a ban on catching fish with hooks I suppose.
ReplyDeleteHello Paul Graham
DeleteI really appreciate your time ..... you are right in saying that , and you have actually highlighted another aspect while saying that people from different ethnicity also get same meat under different circumstances.
Yes i suppose soon we will have something against fishing :) and many other things. May be we will be forbidden to kill pests as well.
I think their laws must come for improvement in living conditions , as there they are suffering for long time , even if we accept that killing is painful , but it is just for few minutes.
I understand why you kill an animal in this way. It also makes sense. Religious or otherwise. I don't agree with "do it my way or the highway". All people should be respected for their beliefs whatever they may be. I am sorry Denmark don't agree.
ReplyDeleteThank you Debbie Harper for your views
DeleteThat is the point that everyone must have a freedom to speak and act as he/she wants.
I think it is sad that we do not accept the differences. It is sad that Muslims are not allowed to practice religion
ReplyDelete